Third Millennium Thought

Month: November 2026

Reality in Three Paradigms

To reply with an email, use: jimsullivannj@comcast.net

 

Overview:

We know that pure science is defined by the fact that its causality is deterministic. its science is typified by deduced algorithms or formulas such as the laws of motion, chemistry or electronics. Its epistemology (How do we know) and definition are unique and clear, when we analyze it using the lens of causality. What about the behavioral sciences, biology and the humanities? Are they science? Do they have a different type of causality? How does it affect our religion, philosophy and ideology? Every time I see an online discussion of “if determinism is strict and exclusive” then “do we have any free will? Is everything we do part of a pre-determined script: aka – the clockwork universe? The following discussion leads to nothing but confusion. There is no excuse for this and a lot of harm. The distinctions may be the most important issue in terms of a humanistic philosophy and the ultimate existential questions such as “Do we have free will?” and “How did we come to exist as conscious beings?” You can not understand this world unless you understand the limits of deterministic causality and then continue into the other, two distinct,  causalities. In those other cases, you must default to analysis of emergence and and self-organization as a separate causality  and address creation – the greatest paradox.

Paradigm: dictionary.com: a framework containing the basic assumptions, ways of thinking, and methodology that are commonly accepted by members of a scientific community.

Here, I want to discuss three paradigms that are centering on three, distinctly different types of causality. This should be of interest to anyone in math, science, philosophy or anyone interested in the existential questions about reality. I am not being overly ambitious in addressing this question. There are some clear answers that are widely accepted, based on science, mathematics and logic.

  • The First Paradigm is the causality of Determinism. It is based on well- defined parameters. Using Deduction, formulas are deduced and verified as the mathematics map to the phenomena as actualized. I will discuss the limits of when it cannot be exclusive and when there must be other causalities.
  • The Second Paradigm is a completely separate and different, as a causality. It is the causality of Emergence and/or Self-Organization. When observed results are not within determinism’s boundaries, it cannot be the exclusive causality.  Instead, using Induction, , you have the causality of Emergence and/or Self-Organization. Other, surprising possibilities are explored and manifested such as life.
  • However, my analytic parsing can exaggerate exclusivity of either in their usual manifestation. In reality, these first two causalities, usually manifest in a resultant combination. One or the other may be dominating but exclusivity of either would be very rare.
  • The Third Paradigm is Creation. It is necessary because of the failure of the first two to cover all causality and so, the questions: “where did everything come from” “Is there a design and a conscious designer” and “What is the purpose?” remains. Logically, the failure of the first two causalities to explain where everything came from demands the existence of a third paradigm and another, unique, distinctive, causality. In this paradigm you must use Induction and/or Abduction. The approach in this essay is limited to proof by verified, observation and logic.

 The First Paradigm – determinism – defined:

Determinism in its purest and abstract form, can best be explained as the causality encountered in the pure sciences. It is typified by the laws of motion and many phenomena in areas such, electronics, energy and chemistry. it is a concept based on:

  1. deductive logic that leads to:
  2. logical proof and mathematical formulas, aka. algorithms, from observed phenomena that match to the deterministic precursors that cuase resultant values.
  3. The algorithms/formulas must be linear and they must have:
  4.  well defined and shared, parameters.
  5. The results are an exact output to any degree of significant number places applicable to all cases within known scope.

Here is an example of the characteristics of deterministic phenomena discovered and supported by deductive logic. This is an algorithm to compute the total cumulative distance an object falls over time:  D=1/2 G x T squared.

D, G, and T are completely defined and known parameters. We could make a spreadsheet, second by second of accumulated distance fallen per unit time. The deduced formula becomes obvious using deduction, and so, an abstract algorithm is deduced that maps to the reality we analyzed. This result of the formula or algorithm is always true and exact to any last level of granularity that you are able to measure and compute. If there was an instance within the defined constraints where the formula was not true, then we would question not only that instance but any this instance of the law of gravity. Deductive Logic leading to deterministic causality demands all or nothing.

Strict, Exclusive Determinism as the only science and causality?

Strict, hard or exclusive determinism has been posed as the only causality.  – From Wikipedia: In the history of science, Laplace’s conjecture in 1814 was the first published articulation of exclusive, strict determinism  C. Laplace and others were absorbing and extrapolating this universal principle from a large wave of advances in Classical Mechanics in the 17th and 18th century. Advances that could, for instance, predict the future movements of all the heavenly bodies indefinitely into the future – limited only by the knowledge and accuracy of the starting state of all parameters. The expansion of proven scientific laws just kept coming most notably by Kepler’s Laws of Planetary Motion (1609 – 1619) Newton’s Laws of Motion (1687), and electrical formulas, etc.

According to strict determinism, if someone i.e., a super intelligence, in his conjecture:  some entity, later coined as “La Place’s demon” captures all information and knows the precise location and momentum of every particle, energy state, or sub-particle in the universe, and their past values, then the future is trapped, causatively bounded i.e. rigidly, exactly predictable to the smallest values of change and movement for all the time to come. If it were true that all outcomes to the finest degree of exactness are caused by deterministic causality alone, then that description  would be correct.

If determinism was exclusive, any human decision making, and free will are false illusions.  You would be pushed to conclude that most important values: love, family, hope religion, ideology, are illusions. It can fundamentally affect the foundation of other belief systems – our political systems, the dignity of man, morality, culture, ideology and religions. All of these are based on free choices, not a relentless machine-like output. In that view, it is a final, un-editable movie reel. It is the basis of materialism. It’s philosophically pushes us towards the logical, but nihilistic conclusion: “what does anything matter?”. Richard Dawkins said ““The universe we observe has precisely the properties we should expect if there is, at bottom, no design, no purpose, no evil and no good, nothing but blind, pitiless indifference.” These distinctions are very important at the highest levels of philosophy, ethics and religion. This can be a poison that kills the human spirit and mocks all morality, and self-sacrifice to ideals bigger than ourselves. It also leads any logic of causation to the question of creation hanging on nothing. The first two, by their own inner logic have, and cannot have a answer.

Many PHD scientist who are brilliant in their field believed clockwork exclusive, determinism, and some, still do. It is a fact that they never had any penetration in the areas that we know are emergent and/or self-organized like life the humanities, behavior of lower lifeforms, human consciousness, the effects of transcendental belief: none. Was there a treatise or book I missed? Where are all – or any – deduced algorithms? They did not address the limits of the manifestation of exclusive determinism’s limits as we shall see. They have no logical answer to creation.

Computers helped open up and explore the field of non-linear algorithms and chaos that map to causality that cannot be deterministic for all ranges of input. These discoveries are called “Chaos Theory”.  Once you hit a range that is non-linear, you pass through, chaos. Like,  Alice in Wonderland’s looking glass, things get “curiouser and curiouser”. The tiniest increment in a driving parameter may bifurcate or jump to an unexpected output value. This was unpredictable! At a later point, further increases are functionally random. There can be no exclusive  determinism in these circumstances. There is mixed determinism. At present, the mainstream of scientist and mathematicians do not believe in the clockwork version. It is not supportable by current knowledge or concurrence. The limits of determinism have been established. They are substantial and numerous. On the other hand possibilities that look like magic are opened up as we shall see.

1 Deductive Logic and deduced algorithms are the epistemology of deterministic causality 

I presented an example of a deterministic law of motion to show how drastically different this causality is from the causality of the outcome of emergence, self-organization. Determinism is entirely different in its epistemology of deriving an exact, closed-form mathematical algorithm with defined parameters using deductive logic. As a contrary example: the three-body problem does not have any linear solution. It is not difficult; it has been logically, mathematically proven to be impossible. Mathematically, the n-body problem is the same. Non-linearity and artifacts (thermal effects etc.) mixed in, are other limits to exclusive determinism. These latter are important because  after changing inputs, then looking at  output results, we see that the  values are very sensitive to starting conditions. Any “artifact” that is not deterministic also causes non-linearity and so diminishes deterministic dominance in a particular process or phenomena.

The limits of determinism:

The limits of determinism, which is a causality, must match closely with the   characteristics used to define it. It must be a process or change that uses deduction to produce an algorithm that uses widely shared parameters. If for a given phenomena an explanation for change does not match the above, then it is not deterministic.

  • If you measure, but do not use known parameters that can be tested as valid like Mass, Length, Temperature. Love or disappointment are not standardized.
  • It cannot deduce an algorithm like – D = g/2 X t^2. If an algorithm comes from. (Working backwards from Curve-fit to assign a likely algorithm -this is not deduction.)
  • The algorithm must have a closed form solution. Three Body or N-Body estimates do not converge on a closed form solution. Question – where do you not have 3 molecules or 3 agents affecting each other? This limit must be near universal even if to a very small degree in a case where determinism is very dominant.
  • Artifacts – that are to be ignored?
    • If they do not negate linearity, they can add to a set of deterministic algorithms that yield a deterministic resultant as in an earth to moon shot.
    • If they do negate linearity than this instance is not deterministic. Examples: a magnet deflects a pendulum. Friction, Chaos.

 

To see the pervasiveness these limitations see: The Three Body Problem and the Limits of Pure, Exclusive Determinism in Additional Topics below. I have not seen anyone else in discussions about the limits of determinism based on the three-body problem, who apply this to anyplace three agents interact – even on the scale of molecules. Name a place where there are not 3 molecules. I was so surprised by my analysis and logical conclusion that I used four AI sources (Chat GBT, Claude, Deep Seek and Grok 3 to verify it. They understood, agreed and amplified. See the four, separate “Discussions with Chat GBT, etc. ….” entries. The surprising conclusion is that the limits of determinism are everywhere. This leads me to the conclusion that the separate causalities of determinism and emergence, as manifested in reality, are mixed to some degree everywhere in our universe! The mix may be dominant for one or the other or more equal in other scenarios.

The Second Paradigm – Emergence and/or Self-Organization – defined:

All of this sounds abstract, so consider the larger fact that, using exclusive determinism, no life would exist. This generative process thrives by escaping the narrow confines of determinism and explores more possibilities.  We would not exist and be conscious. How do you define, and what, are the units of behavior or your consciousness? What are the units of hostility or hope? What algorithms bound their possibilities? I think that the scientists who used their scientific credentials and were experts at scientific method and verification, in their field, have to answer to the fact that they never made any – no – progress outside of pure science. They did not use and limit themselves to  the successful epistemology and verification that was successful  in their field. Could they publish a paper based on these guesses?

  1. Inductive Logic–

By contrast, the causality resulting from emergent and self-organization causality is analyzed by inductive logic and abductive reasoning. We need to understand the difference between these logical disciplines.

Inductive Logic advances sciences seeking knowledge by applying analysis starting with observation.

Inductive reasoning constructs or evaluates general propositions that are derived from specific examples. It uses any tools of science and math that can be tested and are helpful/applicable like correlation or curve-fit. I call this latter type of activity “back engineering” and it can result in very usable or “good-enough” algorithms. These are not the same as deduced algorithms. There is a deterministic set of algorithms that can exactly  compute the theoretical optimal performance of a steam boiler using thermodynamic formulas, but don’t put your hand on it in operation or you will be severely burnt by “artifacts”. An engineer could have warned you.  He probably has tables of values for heat escape for different models. They usually use deterministic (adjective) principles to derive the tables, but they would not be expected to be exact.

Abduction: Abductive reasoning is about forming a conclusion based on the best available explanation. It often involves guesswork and is used when there is incomplete information. In many cases it can be workably accurate while admitting a choice it may not be right.

Emergence and Self-Organization are very different from pure deterministic causality.

Definition and Characteristics of Emergence and Self-Organization from Grok AI.

  1. Emergence:
    • Definition: Emergence refers to the process where complex systems or patterns arise from relatively simple interactions among individual components, resulting in properties or behaviors that are not present in the individual parts.
    • Characteristics:
      • Novelty: The emergent whole exhibits new properties or behaviors not seen in the individual components.
      • Holism: The whole is greater than the sum of its parts, meaning the system’s behavior cannot be fully predicted or explained by analyzing individual elements alone.
      • Unpredictability: Emergent properties are often difficult to predict from the rules governing individual components.
      • Scale Dependence: Emergent phenomena typically manifest at a higher level of organization (e.g., a flock of birds’ coordinated movement vs. individual bird behavior).
      • Examples: Consciousness from neural interactions, ant colony behavior from simple ant rules, or traffic patterns from individual driver decisions.
  2. Self-Organization:
    • Definition: Self-organization is the spontaneous formation of ordered structures or patterns in a system through internal processes, without external control or direction.
    • Characteristics:
      • Spontaneity: Order arises naturally from the interactions of components without a central coordinator or external blueprint. Bird an fly in a synchronized murmuration but no one is in charge.
      • Local Interactions: The system’s components follow simple, local rules, leading to global patterns (e.g., molecules aligning in a crystal).
      • Adaptability: Self-organizing systems can adapt to changes in their environment, often showing resilience or flexibility. Evolution.
      • Decentralized Control: No single component dictates the system’s behavior; order emerges from distributed interactions.
      • It can converge to a new “platform” that has new, unique rules such as life. Life has it own rules. There can be further self-organization to a higher level platform like complex behavior and then consciousness – another, higher platform.

The term emergence does not do justice to what truth has been learned by – observation. Some causality of self-organization may be ordinary in our experience. For example, water forms a whirlpool going down a drain or weather patterns. Some effects of self-organized causality are astounding and could never be deduced or predicted by observing their many components such as life and the reproduction of life-forms driven by a computer-like DNA system. Life is a new platform with its own rules. It develops even higher-level platforms. Every living species is a unique chemical factory with increasing behavioral levels through evolutionary development/emergence. Exclusive determinism could never explain this. The sciences dependent on emergence and self-organization do not explain why things have to happen. These disciplines only allow us to study phenomena dependent on emergence and/or self-organization using the tools of science, logic and math in any way that helps insight in an approximate, measurable way. Their conclusions do advance truth but the verification of exact results is much more difficult and often dependent other on local circumstances. Unlike deterministic science findings the results may not carry over at another time, place or other factors.

In behavioral and similar scientific studies start with observation and correlation to create hypothesis but, without agreed upon rigorous standards, without those standards; correlation can prove that drinking milk causes cancer. Here – we use statistics, measurement, correlation, curve-fit and, but most importantly, standards of Randomized Controlled Trials. This is most obvious in the behavioral and life sciences: Psychology, Biology, Sociology, Ethics etc.). The huge difference is that, at the start, there are, usually, no exactly defined variables. There ae no exact formulas derived from deductive logic. In order to use quantitative analysis, measurables are proposed, evaluated, critiqued and validated later. Similar to determinism, you are dealing with a separate causality and pursuing and achieving truth.

It is true that deterministic processes cannot be directly contradicted. That would be magic, not science of any sort. It also true that wherever self-organization is operative or dominant there is also deterministic effects and the total outcome is the resultant.

The revolution of the mathematic validity of emergent causality and self-organization came about with the increase in computing power. For brevity, I will just use the term “emergence”.

Most times when an algorithm is discovered it is deterministic. There is a notable exception around 1890 by one of the most prolific mathematicians ever. Poincare was the first to understand the possibility of completely irregular, or “chaotic,” behavior of solutions of nonlinear differential equations that are characterized by an extreme sensitivity to initial conditions: Given slightly different initial conditions, outputs can grow exponentially apart with time, so the system soon becomes effectively unpredictable, or chaotic.” These cases cannot be deterministic. Unlike deterministic equations, you cannot compute an exact solution (also called a “closed from solution”). It is not complicated waiting to be solved by a better technique – because mathematics, in some cases, can prove there is no final set of algorithms that will predict a solution for all starting and incremental conditions. An increment in a parameter acting like it is linear may suddenly jump to a discontinuous value. This was an early discovery of the doorway to chaos, emergence and self-organization. When the overall mathematical description of a phase space is non-linear, this is a hard limit to determinism. This is why any three large astronomical bodies are not deterministic and the reason that non-linear property in any three molecules is also not exclusively deterministic. See my other blog entries “Conversations with… Chat GBT and Claude, Deep Seek and Grok as confirmation.

I always anticipated that exclusive determinism could not explain all causative reality. Even in college, Physics 101, 1960, I wondered how a reach of wind over the ocean for 100 miles could cause the emergence of a wave system with 3 measures of periodicity: Height = 30 ft, time – every 30 sec, distance 200 ft apart, however; all the deterministic factors are on the molecular level. Each molecule is an independent agent pushed downward deterministically, by gravity. At depth the pressure gradient is dominantly deterministic but sideway forces are random-like. A wave pattern or structure on the scale of 10 to the 30th on a different order appears. Where did the larger pattern come from? How was that outcome determined? When I saw and grabbed the book Chaos (1987 by James Gleick), I never knew the mathematical basis but, It was a confirmation rather than a discovery. I was deeply impressed by this revelation. This limitation of strict, deterministic causality gives us an image of a picture and these limitations set up a frame for another picture.

Complexity Theory: the theory that processes having a large number of seemingly independent agents can spontaneously order themselves into a coherent system or structure or even entirely new platforms. The starting, deterministic causality may be on the molecular level and the emergence of a structure may be on an immense level 30 ft waves. A dripping faucet may drip deterministically in an exact period. Driven by a higher input, there emerges a periodic fluctuation in timing and, at a higher boundary, after some bifurcations, a random pattern emerges. Some forms of emergence are always present like the thermodynamic structures in weather patterns. Some are a one in a octillion long shot when some mix of organic proteins evolved as life. Improvements in functionality emerged both gradually– over 100 of millions of years. Later this was punctuated by sudden, quantum jumps into a fully coded replication process – RNA DNA, multi-cellular. Life is a new platform with a whole set of new rules and additional, changing, expanding functionality. This DNA is a system of discovery, inventiveness and improvements that are no longer as highly dependent on randomness.

Another characteristic is that emergent/self-ordering phenomena give results that are starkly different from any their components. Exact knowledge of lowest level parameters does not predict outcome on a larger scale.

Examples of structures that start with complexity: whirligig, tornado, hurricane, ocean wave system, DNA, life, consciousness.

I am going to use Chat GPT as confirmation in a way that uses it strongest suit. It gathers immense amounts of data and reflects a consensus of opinion in technical areas among other things.  I am trying to explain the relationship of Emergence and Self-Organization to the surprising – without exaggeration- astounding  – discoveries of the mathematical foundations of the mechanism of emergence – the logistics map, the Mandelbrot set. Observations in physical systems followed. I want to establish that this is not a narrow or controversial opinion. Its basis is a broad consensus of latest research. This is strict, validated science.

The conversations with Chat GPT – see at the end:  Confirming the nature of determinism as a cause vs Self-organization as a separate type of cause in Additional Topics below

I also posed the same series of questions to Claude AI, Deep Seek AI and Grok AI with similar results and with no corrections. See my other blog entries starting with Conversations with

.…

 

Conclusion we now know:

The conjecture or any conclusion that – the causality of determinism is exclusive and. Therefore; we live in a fixed, clockwork universe is proven invalid. This is accepted at the highest levels of math, logic and science.  Yet, why it is still being discussed seriously to this day?

It has been proven empirically, logically and mathematically that there is another causality – emergence and self-organization – and these two causalities work together to explain all physical, material phenomena – within the Universe. It is also proven that, of course, we have free will. We exercise it and feel it all our lives!

I have not referred to Quantum Mechanics because I do not have a background in it sufficient to cite it. At a high level, I have to say that anything I have seen on this subject as far as my understanding goes, is supportive of non-determinism. I never saw any support in this arena for exclusive, strict determinism.

To be clear about the fact that they work together: it is also true that some phenomena are dominantly deterministic such as the laws of motion and some are dominantly emergent/self-organized such as the beginning of reproductive life or transcendental beliefs, like faith or hope, that are also causative.

In the opening of The Lord of the Rings, there is a line that says, “In those early days, there were laws of nature and magic.” By the causality of emergence/self-organized phenomena, this is where all the “magic” happens. You have passed through the looking glass (chaos).

Let me define magic. If I had two standard pool eight balls, one when released falls from your hand. The other eight ball stays floating in the air after saying the magic words. This does not exist, but if it did, that would be a definition and an instance of magic. It defies deterministic laws of nature. Standing in the conceptual arena of determinism – looking out at what is caused by Emergence/Self-Organization which does not have deterministic causality – your assessment would be that you are seeing “magic”. Yes – beyond the world of determinism we live in a world that has vast area that are magic-like”. Accept and celebrate the “magic”. This is also truer and at a deeper level when we look at creation as a whole. When we look at all the wonder in the Universe it takes the sense of “magic” to another level.

 

The Third Paradigm: Creation

The universe is proposed/defined as everything. It includes all of space, and all the matter and energy that space contains. It even includes time itself.

If we consider the first paradigm as a picture, the inability of the first paradigm to explain all causality creates an empty frame. What is the picture that fills that frame?

The addition of the causality of emergence and self organization fills out the picture of the second paradigm.

The inability of either the first or second paradigm to explain the biggest question – why does anything – the Universe –  exist – sets up another frame for the Third Paradigm: Creation. What picture  do we put in this frame?

At this point we have to use abduction.

What is the one very big thing that neither the causality of the second paradigm can even begin to explain?

Oh- the Universe. Its existence, Its causality.

As Stephen Meyer said “You can’t absolutely prove the existence of God, but the consequences of denying the existence of God, as a theoretical postulate at least, is a system of physics which ends up eating its own; which ends up destroying, for epistemological reasons, our ability to rely on our own reasoning capabilities about the world around us. So at the end, the choice is between God and science, or no God and no science.“.

So far we see that there is another frame by the negatives from the first two paradigms. But the Third Paradigm must have positive aspects or the picture contains nothing. This would mean that the other 2 causalities had no place to act. This causality must be chronologically prior to the other two.

 

 


How can we progress toward an understanding of the likely properties of the third paradigm? Fundamentally – what could create, and be the cause of, our universe?

Wikipedia under “History of Religion”  – “The earliest archeological evidence suggests the emergence of religious ideas dates back several hundred thousand years, to the Middle and Lower Paleolithic periods: some archaeologists conclude that the apparently intentional burial of early Homo sapiens and Neanderthals and even Homo Naledi as early as 300,000 years ago is proof that religious ideas already existed, but such a connection is entirely conjectural.” The philosophic questions resonant with religion are as innate to homo sapiens as his self-aware consciousness.

At this point I want to propose a view of levels of ascension in areas that are past the material and show properties increasing in complexity, information and other aspects of causality in several dimensions. Their epistemology is not supported by material, algorithms as in the causality of determinism.  They do point to a causality based on information, unique processes and an explosion of design in living things, behavior and consciousness leading to other causalities in the area of transcendental causes that is not explained by emergence/self-organization. From this I see a vision of upward ascendance.

What are the compounding levels of organization, platforms, an inventive system. This is not just rapid but a steep acceleration of new platforms on higher levels and a generative environment that makes recursive improvements in the very tools and processes of invention. Examples: – DNA?.  Human drives and activities that are transcendent. What is the new level of consciousness, conceptualization, and a systematic, deliberate culture from new causality working in the sphere of information, ideas, ideology, transcendent values and religion. Why have homo sapiens exhibited, throughout their history, an inherent, increasing drive  to address the ultimate questions of the third paradigm?

Ascendance and an improvements from a  Generative environment.

I see a higher level of ascendance in the history of man in the universe. I do have faith in man’s vision of a shared, common sense of justice and good, especially when it is based on natural law and this sense is made even more insightful by a progression of movements such as later religions in various forms, the renaissance, humanism. I see an elevated ethical structure rising past early empires that believed the strong should exploit the weak and their gods expected this of warrior cultures. I see a clear progression when I think of “All men are created equal and they are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights.” This level is recognizable to all people as a shared sense of good and justice but is both progressed and degraded throughout our history. This, at the top of ascendance would reflect on the mind of God as the third paradigm.

Even in a secular based system, at its best, this view placed individuals with all different beliefs in a social contract to put individual rights over government and to limit government. Universal, unalienable set the stage and a legal system to work with differences. Can anyone say that this progression has not emerged from  a religious view across mankind as created?  I feel that to progress I have to dig deeper to come to grip with God’s plan for us, individually and as a people.

Conclusion, Faith or Best Choice?

I have a deep sense that I am standing on a staircase of ascendence that was created by an a generative process that was innate in its deterministic causality as a base. It was also innate in what we now know as emergence and self-organization as a different causality. The sense of hierarchy is highest when considering man , his consciousness and our use of transcendence that seems to go beyond any physical limit or causality.  Now do we find an answer for creation looking down and see something at the deterministic, material base? There is only raw material in the structures of suns, galaxies and planets. I feel like I am trying to interview a rock.

I took out most of my previous writing on this subject because it is wandering and apologetic. I have faith in the religious teachings about ethics and morality. I especially respect the role of religion in denying materialism, supporting families, stressing communities that help all members and any human. I did have a problem relating this to the logical structure I was using as a guideline in the first two paradigms. I feel there is a gap in pursuing what we know, as an entire community with differing religions about God using logic and and what we observe. I also felt there is a deficit as a christian in its foundation since it appears that we do not have any direct feedback from God in two thousand years. I have prayed to God to address this in my individual search for truth about God as creator, his purpose, and the existence of any afterlife.

Just recently I have seen many You Tube videos about a seeming breakthrough in the curtain between the living and the dead. Using knowledge of brain surgeons and Neuroscientist acting as scientist, verified by the same inductive science used in other behavioral science, we are accumulating a large body of evidence about consciousness not being in the material brain and other related topics.

I am going to pursue this in another entry.

 

To reply with an email, use: jimsullivannj@comcast.net

 


Additional Topics:

These are an amplification on previous discussions.

The Three Body Problem and the Limits of Exclusive Determinism

Where do the limits of exclusive determinism start. Contrary to the La Place’s conjecture, which was later expanded to a widely held materialistic philosophy, It turns out it is closer than anyone thinks, and probably everywhere. Lets consider the three body problem.

I submitted this to ChatGPT:

Question:

When three astronomical bodies a have gravitational attraction that is operating simultaneously. This is called the three body problem. There can be back-engineered formulas or techniques for getting close solutions. For a completely deterministic solution, is there a mathematical reason that we can not get the exact solution?

Answer: This is an extract. I truncated the end, because it was repetitive with extraneous text.

ChatGPT:

Yes, the “three-body problem” in the context of celestial mechanics refers to the challenge of predicting the motions of three celestial bodies under the influence of their mutual gravitational attraction. This problem is notoriously difficult to solve exactly due to its inherent complexity, and it’s a classic example of a chaotic system in physics.

The primary reason for the difficulty in finding an exact, closed-form solution to the three-body problem lies in its mathematical nature. When you have three or more interacting bodies, the equations that describe their motion become highly nonlinear and interdependent. These equations cannot be solved using simple algebraic or analytical methods, as they do not have straightforward closed-form solutions like many simpler problems in physics.

Additionally, there are other reasons to modify determinism as exclusive such as environmental artifacts that affect linearity . In chaos theory, small changes in initial conditions can lead to drastically different outcomes over time. This sensitivity to initial conditions makes long-term predictions for complex systems like the three-body problem extremely challenging, if not impossible, to make with high precision.

End of ChatGPT.

Conclusion:

So even Kepler’s laws of motion are undone, by science and mathematics, by three or more  planets that are gravitationally interconnected. I see an overall conclusion that –  when three molecules interact this nullifies exclusive determinism.
Try to think of an example where you do not have three bodies. Try to name a real-life phenomena where you do not have some emergence. Try to think of a place where you do not have some deterministic causality. While deterministic is mixed into the total causality and is also almost everywhere, we now know that determinism alone is very rare. We live in a deterministic and complex universe.


 

Confirming the nature of determinism as a cause vs Self-organization as a separate type of cause

The bolded portions for emphasis was made by me. 

My Chat GPT entry:

I am writing a Blog that, I think, presents the broad, scientifically established opinion on the essential difference in causality between exclusive, strict determinism and the causality of emergence – self organization. I highlight the differences as 2 paradigms – The First Paradigm is exclusive, strict determinism and I say it is not valid when presented as exclusive because strict determinism is not sufficient to describe the causality of all known phenomena. I am positing that the First Paradigm – strict determinism is not valid as exclusive. I am positing a Second Paradigm is determinism, but; the Second Paradigm also includes emergence, self-organization – both – this is the valid view. I do not separate them because, in the real world, both work together for a resultant outcome. Determinism is based on deduction that yields formulas that have well known parameters as opposed to emergence. Emergence, self-organization is based on initial observations, we then use scientific methods and mathematical analysis and these yield results that are better than any known alternative. In large areas such as evolution and human behavioral studies, emergence is the only way to proceed because they are based on emergent phenomena. Please clarify, correct if necessary, and expand in the voice of the current, broad consensus on this discussion. Explain how the theory of emergence is mathematically based after computer advances allowed exploration of the logistics map and the Mandelbrot set. Explain how scientist also supported this by scientific concurrence in experimental and observational studies. Emergence was a shocking and totally unexpected outcome and the mathematics and science support observation of many real-life examples of emergence leading from weather up to life and consciousness. Make any ratification/agreement or correction you see fit.

End of first question

ChatGPT Answer: 05/31/2023   (my bold)

In the realm of causality and the understanding of complex phenomena, there has been an ongoing debate between two paradigms: strict determinism and emergence/self-organization. The broad, scientifically established consensus acknowledges that strict determinism alone is insufficient to describe the causality of all known phenomena. This realization has led to the recognition and acceptance of a Second Paradigm that combines determinism with the concept of emergence and self-organization. 

The First Paradigm, exclusive strict determinism, asserts that every event in the universe is determined by preceding causes, following a linear chain of cause and effect. However, it has become evident that this view is limited in its ability to explain various complex systems and phenomena. The Second Paradigm encompasses both determinism and emergence/self-organization, recognizing that these concepts work together to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the world.

Determinism, is based on deduction and seeks to establish causal relationships using well-defined parameters and formulas. It relies on the idea that given the initial conditions and the laws governing a system, the future behavior can be predicted with certainty. Deterministic models have been successful in explaining a wide range of phenomena, particularly in the physical sciences.

On the other hand, emergence and self-organization are based on the observation of complex systems and their behaviors. They take into account the idea that certain properties or patterns can arise spontaneously from the interactions of simpler components, leading to emergent phenomena that cannot be solely deduced from the properties of individual components. The study of emergence has gained significant momentum after advances in computer technology allowed for the exploration of complex mathematical systems like the logistics map and the Mandelbrot set. These mathematical models showcased the unexpected and fascinating behavior that emerges from relatively simple rules, providing a strong foundation for the concept of emergence.

Moreover, the scientific community has supported the theory of emergence through experimental and observational studies across various fields. One notable example is the study of evolution, where emergent phenomena, such as the emergence of new species and the diversification of life forms, cannot be explained solely through determinism. Similarly, in human behavioral studies, emergent properties like collective behavior, cultural dynamics, and consciousness cannot be understood by reducing them to deterministic principles.

The recognition of emergence as a valid perspective is not just based on theoretical considerations; it is backed by empirical evidence and real-life examples. The behavior of weather systems, for instance, exhibits emergent patterns that arise from the interactions of atmospheric elements. Emergence has also been observed in biological systems, where complex behaviors and functionalities emerge from the interactions of simpler organisms or cells.

In summary, the current, broad consensus within the scientific community acknowledges that the exclusive, strict determinism of the First Paradigm is insufficient to explain the causality of all known phenomena. The Second Paradigm, which combines determinism with emergence and self-organization, offers a more comprehensive and accurate understanding of complex systems. This perspective recognizes that both deterministic principles and emergent phenomena work together to shape the world we observe. The mathematical foundations of emergence, supported by advancements in computer science, coupled with empirical evidence from various scientific disciplines, provide a solid basis for embracing emergence as a vital aspect of causality in the natural world.

End of Chat-GPT answer.

(By the way, as a check, I tried the same question in another AI: Claude and got essentially the same answer.

My follow-up Chat-GPT question:

The Mandelbrot set is claimed to be deterministic because a computer-generated set with specific parameters, if repeated, will generate the exact same output. It is said that this shows it is both emergent and deterministic. Comment on the limitation of a computer simulation vs real life. There almost always many artifacts in real life that will variegate output such as thermal factors and other background artifacts. In real life, with complex parameters, under these circumstances, repeated submissions are not deterministic. These artifacts are not marginal in a system where starting factors, though infinitesimal, will amplify variance in output. In fact, some systems of emergence such as evolution thrive on computational causality with a little artifact effects mixed in.

ChatGPT answer 5-31-2023

You make a valid point regarding the limitations of computer simulations compared to real-life phenomena. While computer simulations, such as generating the Mandelbrot set, can be considered deterministic in the sense that given the same starting parameters, they will produce the same output, they do not fully capture the complexities and variability present in real-life systems.

In real-life scenarios, there are numerous factors that can introduce variability or artifacts, leading to deviations from deterministic outcomes. These factors can include environmental influences, stochastic processes, random fluctuations, and the presence of background artifacts like thermal factors you mentioned. These variations can have a significant impact on the behavior and outcomes of complex systems.

In the case of emergence, where interactions among components give rise to novel properties and behaviors, the presence of these artifacts becomes even more pronounced. Complex systems often have multiple interacting parameters, and even small variations in these parameters or the presence of external artifacts can lead to divergent outcomes. This sensitivity to initial conditions, commonly referred to as the butterfly effect, implies that even infinitesimal changes can propagate and amplify over time, resulting in significant differences in the system’s behavior.

While deterministic principles still play a role in understanding emergent phenomena, the inherent variability and non-linearity present in real-life systems necessitate a broader perspective. It is precisely the interplay between deterministic principles and the effects of artifacts or variability that allows for the emergence of novel properties and behaviors. Evolution, as you mentioned, is a prime example of a system where computational causality (deterministic principles) interacts with the influence of external factors or artifacts (variability) to drive the emergence of diverse life forms.

End of Chat GPT answer

 


 

To reply with an email, use: jimsullivannj@comcast.net

 

 

 

 

Wealth Inequality in America – Our Biggest Problem

If you want to contact me,  my email is:   jimsullivannj@comcast.net

I knew this was a major problem. Now I have been further educated by several Substack sites. They have presented several undeniable statistics which show that the US is headed into strategic decline economically and demographically. The issues I present here are the biggest and most strategic in terms of our future. I do not exaggerate. The basic epistemology (how do we know?) is validated by , stark, undeniable  statistics.

Graph 1

This looks like it was originally Statistica sourced. I first saw this on Michael Synder’s Substack   –  https://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/ – Great Information there.

:

 

 

If you even glance at Graph 1, it appears spectacular and; it is. Believe your eyes. Do yourself a favor and look again. The US economy is supposed to be driven in a “virtuous circle”. Consumption (final sales) provides producer-entrepreneurs with more investment money for more production focused on consumer’s growing needs needs. As production/consumption grows, more jobs are created and this increasing income feeds increased buying levels , and so on.

This is what economist call “the Virtuous Circle”.  Consumption is a necessary step in the chain. Consumer consumption is  70% of our GDP. The distortion we see locks up this flow. The graph is about Total Wealth. Wealth is not a yearly flow; it is a measure of a cumulative effect for all the years preceding, it is a multi-year dynamic accumulation and acts as a compounding driver. It is still following this trend. Accumulated Asset Value is not production. The highest levels of government present  the Stock Markets – exclusively – as the total picture of economic health. This is absurd.  Increasing numbers of ordinary people can struggle, go broke and end up homeless regardless of the stock market valuation.  The cohort which is the bottom 80% of income is not in stock investment.

The bottom 50% have 1% of investment. The Wealthy live in an isolated sub-culture. They do not want to understand the deterioration in the ability of the  masses to hold on to what they have. All forms of debt: Corporate, Government, and private are funded and continue the illusion by debt growth eating away at our children’s and grandchildren’s future). This is not sustainable as Capitalism. It is explained elsewhere by all the realist who predicted past downturns, that the end is near here because there is no way out. This level of debt cannot be repaid nor can it be sustained. The debt is in the hundreds of thousands for each tax paying unit. This is true in the US and many other nations. There will be inflation, stagflation, and finally collapse.  After this, a new level of liquidity crisis and we will be stuck in deflation. This is  a classic pattern repeated in history.

The effects of Wealth inequality also appears in big money contribution dominating in our election cycles and government administration. Just one example: consider what it did to our handling the Covid Pandemic. “it’s the science” ?  More than 2 dozen US agencies knew that it was from the Wuhan lab immediately. The Lancet, a top level medical science publication, originally stated the truth. They were persuaded by Fauchi to reverse and received millions in subsidies after they did. See any pattern?  I knew Covid’s obvious origin  and how honest researchers knew it was gain of function; I knew about cleavage sites, AE2 and all that. It was known in 2 months that it is like a mild flu for children. Later it was known that it was causing an elevation in miscarriages. This was discussed with Fauchi and dismissed. States like Florida and entire countries like Sweden knew the draconian measures were based on many lies. They had the same outcomes by ignoring those measures. Pharmaceuticals are the biggest contributor of  corporate donations to election donations. Money? The RNA treatment (Calling it a vaccine is the initial lie). could not be approved if there was a safe alternative by law. This was the reason for the great distortion.  An alternative treatment: Ivermectin – used and proven, like aspirin, in the rest of the world for decades, was widely propaganisized as toxic horse medicine by decree. Excess lives were lost. There was no real science, only self- serving distortion.  At this point, the only publicly stated justification for any government action is “the broad common good”.  In practice, this is a pose.  Our democracy by representation does not function under these conditions. This is another effect of The Wealth Gap.

If you think this is dramatic or over-dramatic watch this You Tube video that focuses on what Americans think the Wealth Distribution is like. It is 13 years old so it is significantly worse. It proves the public has no clue. This is another reason representative government fails.

Graph 1 and the You Tube was like a slap in the back of my head when i first saw it. It was a deserved slap because we are kept so dumb. It gets worse:

Wait to you hear the bad news:

Graph 2  This looks like Statistica sourced. I first saw this  By 

 

 

Graph 2 is worse in its strategic implications because it shows the long-term future of our country.  Only families provide a future for the United States in the long run. Can you think of another model?  What the graph shows about family formation reveals an alarming problem.  At present it seems, the news analysts have no idea why so many people are voting for socialism. As the reality unfolds, this will drive the worst instincts: it is an emotional driver of detachment, or anger, and a feeling that we should let it all crash. This could be addressed by an honest disclosure to everyone by the financial mass media and politicians but that would interrupt the party with all its excesses.  Th e default is to desperately insist everything is great financially. This leaves the public to react to  a growing sense of dissonance that must give way to a growing sense of helplessness as reality imposes, to a sense of alarm, even despair, and at the later stage – panic.

I am in my 80’s and I knew for decades that the younger generations was getting screwed. They can not  buy a house or some other equivalent. Nor, if you are responsible, to have children. The social contract that I faced and drove my parents was so much more inviting and reachable. The graph is stark in proving this. The present rate of formation of a household and raising children by 30 years of age  is 13%  in 2024. This is 1/4 of the 53% in 1950 which was normal and viable. Statistics! No wonder the ambition, the drive and the dream is not the same for the next generations. You don’t have to be a sociologist or a demographer to understand the implications.  Analysis comparing age cohorts that assess or compare blame and judgement are nonsense.  Also, to assess logically and mathematically you should  know that the Reproduction rate has to be 2.1 for every couple to keep the population even. This essay is about the U.S.  but it is of note that this is happening all over many countries and in Asia.  I asked co-pilot AI about our reproduction rate.

Co-Pilot: “Short answer: The current U.S. population reproduction rate (NRR) is about 0.78, far below the replacement equilibrium level of 1.0 and consistent with a total fertility rate (TFR) of ~1.63, which is well below the 2.1 children per woman needed for long‑term population stability.”

The 1.63 statistic  is the shortfall compared to the 2.1 minimum needed for stability. The momentum in the  decline is judged irreversible. . We may be on our way out. Don’t blame me. I am just the messenger. Knowing will not make it any worse. For you: knowing could allow planning to minimize damage. This i s also the story for China, South Korea and many other countries.

How do you feel about top business leaders, our two parties and our media paying no attention to these issues?

It is fair to ask me or anyone “So what is the solution” One big item is to overturn the Supreme Court Decision to allow Corporations to donate billions of dollars tp politicians through many avenues. It was supported by the right to free speech on the basis that corporations are people. I worked for some of the biggest corporations in the US and  I can tell you this is wrong on many levels. Ever hear of a drafted soldier facing death in combat turn to his corporation companion to share his fate? When AT&T had a 100’s of thousands of employees  did they have any say over the Board’s positions. The ratio of board members to employees would be 10,100 to 1. The employees could not stand up on a soap box in their cubicle and give an impassioned speech to effect the top dozen decision makers. The court case must have been presented badly. The right of free speech is an individual’s right. There are many more areas such as public education in the mechanisms that have gone bad by the effects of big money. Look up this headline :

“MF Global Bankruptcy & Jon Corzine’s TRS: $1.6B Went Missing” 

There was criminal misuse of money. A perp-walk would have done wonders. The same applies to the 2008 meltdown. The shadow of big money and political power insures immunity. Does the public know how President Clinton pushed through legislation that helped set up the 2008 financial crisis? Is either mainstream party addressing this problem at this time?

 

 

 

Near Death Experience – A Scientific Proof of Eternal Life

To contact me, since the comment mechanism does not always work, you can email be at jimsullivannj@comcast.net

 

Before I  address Creation and Near Death Experian, I want to establish that what is presented  here is supported by science. I have already examined and defined in the previous post:  – Reality in Three Paradigms – the types of science as defined by causality, that is a the most distinguishing aspect in defining them.  The science supporting the characteristics of Near Death Experience (NDE) is not deterministic science. There are no algorithms involved. The science is emergence/self-organization. For this type the logic of Induction leads to a theories of Self-Organization such as life, behavior and human consciousness. The science presented here is an extension of that.

Here is a start in addressing the issues involved:

  • Creation
    • How can something come out of nothing.
    • If the Universe “always” existed – always means infinity – 101 million years is not even a drop the bucket of infinity. How come we see a progression starting 13 billion years ago just to start with Hydrogen, helium and lithium.
    • The issues are who or what created the universe?
    • What logical-based knowledge do we have about the issues involved in questions about creation?
    • If the creator was a sentient, intelligent entity/person was there a design?
    • Did the creator always exist?
    • What is His intent?
    • How do humans fit into the design?
    • I was always concerned as a Christian that there seems there has been no new, direct revelation about these questions in 2,000 years. I prayed to God about this because the leap of faith does not feel right and sufficient to me. Its just the way I was born. I am not criticizing the entire spectrum of people’s faith-based knowledge. It has been far ahead of this new information. We are individuals and have our own path.
    • All these questions and answers are, to me, addressed because I finally took note of a cascade of articles, interviews and You Tube videos about Near Death Experiences (NDEs). This has engendered more questions.
      • Is there a future for humans after biological death?
      • Have we gone through the barrier between the living and the dead?
      • Have they brought back verifiable information? Was it validated?
      • Is there scientific evidence answering the neuroscientists’ and other scientist’s question about “The hard problem about consciousness.
      • Are experiencers reporting in very large numbers about a heavenly realm that sometimes sends them back to earth with instructions to inform everyone? Others remain in heaven or have a choice to be re-incarnated?
      • What does this new, directed testament tell us about the plan of creation? Is this under God’s provenance? In the feedback from NDE there is a consistent answer about the plan for mankind and many other things.
    • Let me explain where I am going. Millions of people experienced Near Death Experience while they were clinically dead, In the case of a hospital setting, they were monitored with medical machines that can certify death without question. They were dead by any scientific measure. In many cases they had pads over their eyes.
    • When medical teams resuscitated them, they came back to describe what they saw  Many of them described a heavenly realm along with encounters even up to the level of talking to God. They discussed and learned of God’s plan for His  creation.
      • The new scientific information, as I will explain, should be considered the same evidence as in any medical or any life science. This new information then points to consciousness  manifesting outside the human body to another, dimension-like realm. By the standard of abduction there is no other credible candidate. This is unique since the lower brain functions are expressed from the physical brain only. We now know that conscious is not expressed from the physical brain. We have credible witness by at least 1,000,000’s of people who had near-death experiences. We also have the science derived from these experiences.
      • Consciousness is the highest mental faculty that integrates all other gathered intelligence and comes to the conceptual and operative awareness of ourselves, and give us our awareness of self and agency. Beyond deduction, it has a reflexive reaction to multiple, complex inputs that are not easily categorized or analyzed nor do we have any easy explanation for its outcome as manifested. It deduces truth in math and science. It can appreciate a mother’s unconditional love, or any intense human love. A picture, a poem a theory or a gesture, can invoke it whole. It is at the top of all our mental faculties. As we shall see it does not express through our material brain. The material brain is the organ of movement, perception, memory and emotion but not consciousness.
      • In the emerging view as explained by a neuroscientist,  Dr Egnor (who has participated in over 7,000 brain procedures as a neurosurgeon and a teacher), on his many You Tube videos and books is that all living things have a soul that makes them unique. Mankind’s unique feature is that we have consciousness. NDE introduces the idea that we have a soul and a spirit body and this is the vessel of consciousness and the explanation of consciousness operating outside of our bodies.
      • Dr Penrose a noble prize winner in physics and other scientist have a tentative explanation of its unique communication and processes in a quantum field. I am still trying to follow this new science. This quantum field is dimension-like and it supports all information and knowledge. It organizes information intrinsic to an individual and this is where the place consciousness is operative.
      • In the overall history of scientific neuroscience, it was known that there was no explanation to map consciousness to the physical brain. It was called “the hard problem of consciousness” by neuroscientist and neuro-surgeons who were also scientists.”
      • Creation beliefs about a heavenly realm or any view including a known almighty creator – designer previously seemed to be closed off scientifically because of a seeming impenetrable wall between the living and the dead. It was widely believed that once a person dies, there is no more information to support the ideas of further existence.
      • Creation, God, his heavenly realm and human consciousness are addressed by the new revelations highlighted by Near Death Experiences. The wall between the living and the dead is breached and supported by scientific evidence!
      • I have to correct previous references of creation as a type of cause. A causality has three steps. First you have a state. Second you transform, process or change. Third you have a new state. In the case the existence of God , there was no creation He always was.  In the case of the Universe, it was created by God.
        • The seeming absolute wall between the living and the dead has been pierced by numerous accounts of human consciousness experiencing another realm in Near Death Experiences (NDE), often heavenly and transformative, with clear scientific proof that this is not any dream or hallucination or any known experience from our material brain. Neuroscientist know Dreams and Hallucination present completely different characteristics. The biggest is that they are chaotic and vague. This conclusion is backed by the doctors and specialist-neurosurgeons over many years of observation and experience.
        • It is not true that to be a scientifically validated, there is a requirement that the observations have to be supported by repeatable lab experiments. That is not even true if limited to deterministic causality. No one repeated Einstein’s deflected Mercury passage in a lab. The planet Mercury does not fit in any lab. Biological science accepted the emergence of discovery of gorillas in Africa and kangaroos in Australia solely by the first encounter, observations and pictures. This was emergence and testimony and it become accepted, verified science. After analysis they were placed into the taxonomy of evolution by scientist. While logical, science-based skepticism is certainly appropriate, I am puzzled why anyone even tries those “laboratory” gambits. They are easily disproven by those knowledgeable in science. This is one of the reasons I re-visited the prior causalities with their starkly different epistemology and means of scientific validation.
        • In modern times, materialists were dead-set not to consider any such possibility. For many in the materialist sub-culture, their religious position was anti-religion. Information about NDEs was suppressed even to the point of costing your job or reputation.This was described by medical staff assigned to Cardiac Crisis units and Neurosurgeons that heard or observed it in patients and only discussed it with other receptive and safe staff. I did not know that during that period: One early person, Dr. Long, nevertheless,  compiled a data base of 5,000 occurrences.
        • Many NDE experiencers stopped talking about it to friends and family because it seemed to upset them to consider such a thing. Some of this came from seeming contrary religious belief. The later memories of the experiencers, characteristically, did not diminish at all compared to other memories, even in details. Most were deeply affected with a new value system and priorities for the rest of their life.
        • I have seen reports of NDE in prior years but I thought it was very rare, and so, not very supportable, or useful. in fact there were many reports in the mid-70s but there was also an atmosphere of suppression.
        • How widespread are the reports of NDEs? I asked Co-Pilot AI.


Me:

Is there any estimates of how many near death experiences: NDE are reported in the last ten years

COPILOT AI:

Short answer: There is no global database that counts near‑death experiences (NDEs) by year, so we do not have a precise “last ten‑year” total. But we can estimate how many people likely reported NDEs in the past decade using prevalence data from large surveys.

📌 What the research shows (grounded in published data)

  1. General population prevalence

Multiple large surveys show that 4%–10% of people report having had an NDE at some point in life. Some studies find similar ranges worldwide (4%–10%). IANDSIANDS. IANDS Q&A: What Percentage of the Population has Had an NDE?

A newer U.S. survey found a much higher figure: 23% of American adults reported an NDE. This is unusually high compared to earlier research, but it shows how strongly results depend on definitions and survey methods.

  1. Clinical (medical crisis) prevalence

Among people who survive cardiac arrest or similar medical emergencies, 10%–20% report NDEs.

📌 Estimating “last ten years” reports

Because NDEs are usually reported long after they occur—and because surveys ask about lifetime experiences—researchers do not track NDEs by year. However, we can estimate:

Method:

Use prevalence × population over a decade.

Global estimate (approximate):

  • World population ≈ 8.1 billion
  • If 4%–10% have had an NDE, that’s 324 million–810 million people globally.
  • If even 5% of these people reported their experience within the last decade, that’s 16–40 million reports worldwide.

  • I do not consider this answer to be anything but a rough estimate in order of magnitude. My question was about a 10 yr period and was not detailed in the inclusion factors.
  • I think there is enough information after some over-cautious discounting to support a word-wide estimate by 1 year increment: at least a few million per year. This is not trivial or rare. The US occurrence per year would be in the order of magnitude of 10’s of thousands per year. The rate is increasing because of the improving medical science of resuscitation.
  • Before I continue, I would like to clear up some points about the terminology. I have to admit, as a conceptual person, that this is a shocking revelation to me and also to medical doctors and scientific researchers. I want to clear up the terminology and vocabulary. I will continue to use the term “Near Death Experience” because it has become a standard. As we will see these experiences are actually “After Death Experiences”.
  • I would like to be clear in establishing that medical personnel and scientist know when a person is dead. An EKG monitor is a scientific instrument that does not lie. There are many other measures in continuous monitoring. When the EKG is flat, breathing stops, and there is no heart-beat, no circulation, no oxygenation, no continuous glucose: in less than 30 seconds, the brain must be functionally stopped and it is actually brain-dead.
  • When we think and read of description of what the experiencers “see” and “hear”, we constantly normalize to think of their earthly physical, biological, eyes and ears. This is completely wrong. Usually, patients eyes were covered in surgical pads to protect corneas, stress and for other reasons. These people  are brain dead.  In any event, there is no possibility of a functional connection between the dead brain and sensory organs. The logical conclusion is that they see and hear by there spirit body senses. There is even an account of a blind people who saw clearly, in 360 degrees. All possible functions of their brain are inoperable. All their senses were connected to a dead, completely shut down to any processing or handling sensory inputs. I have to be stark here to aid understanding. They could not see or hear anything with the body’s eyeballs and ears in the operating room or adjacent places. Their sense inputs are from their spirit bodies’s senses.
  • In cases of NDE, when they are hovering  above they are enthusiastic in noting that their eyesight is better than they could explain. in traveling to the heavenly realm, their eyesight in vastly enhanced , sometimes operating in 360 degrees. Hearing is also beyond previous experience. Colors and music are beyond anything on earth. If we are scientific and logical, we have to understand that they are using their “spirit” eyes and ears in perfect spirit bodies and have a calm, unfrightened aspect of mind. They are immersed in a “indescribable level of love and belonging. No crew of the best professional Hollywood writers and designers would be able to achieve a audio-visual product capable of resulting in this consistent, testified output in less than 10 minutes in some cases.
  • All of this is emergent science. This is why I say there is scientific proof. Information and testimony is validated after the experience by staff and in some cases investigators.
  • One of the better science-based introductions I have seen on You Tube is a lecture by Dr Michael Egnor “Is the Soul Real?”. He has participated in over 7000 brain surgeries. Since these neurosurgeons are also scientist, they experiment while performing surgeries and share data. Common procedures are to repair aneurisms or to address severe epilepsy conditions. In the course of these procedures, they constantly brain map a specific location to a precise physical location. In all the decades of shared results, they could not maintain their materialist beliefs that all brain functions come from physical areas of the brain. They previously shared the belief that the brain is a flesh and blood biological machine. Its synapses should have explained everything. But they never encountered any data about the top level – consciousness. As I said: “In the overall history of scientific neuroscience, it was known that there was no explanation to map consciousness to the physical brain. It was called “the hard problem of consciousness.”
  • Dr Egnor explained the extreme cases of persons born with astounding deficits of brain morphology. In some cases, most of the mass of both hemispheres is void of brain tissue and filled with water. Patients born with these deficits often astounded medical experts when they went on college and became professionals of notable achievements. This is a complete rebuttal to any case for brain being limited in top level processes to the physical matter of the brain – materialism. Not only is the processing to material mapping missing in normal development but in these cases, there is scientific evidence that it does not follow the rules of any other single organ that cannot function at the same level with clear deficits.
  • Pam Reynolds:
  • You Tube – BBC Pam sees God NDE
  •   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WNbdUEqDB-k
  • The most spectacular case for a person with Near Death Experience, that is functionally like a laboratory experiment, is the case of Pam Reynolds. All her brain functions were shut down and all senses blocked as she was on the operating table. Her brain was clinically dead it was not capable of gathering information that was later related and  verified. There is a YouTube video made of a broadcast by the BBC. The neurosurgeon was Dr. Robert Spetzler. Because the danger of runaway bleeding from a large aneurysm, a large bubble, at the base of her brain, her body was brought down to 60 degrees and the blood processing machine drained all the blood out of her brain. As. I said, medical personnel and scientist know when a person is dead, in fact, they are making sure of it as part of the plan. An EKG monitor is a scientific instrument that does not lie. There are many other measures in continuous monitoring. When the EKG is flat, breathing stops, and there is no heart-beat, no circulation no oxygenation. Her eyes were taped. Two speakers, continuously clicking, were taped over each ears as part of the instrumentation to make sure this is no brain activity, as intended. The EKG and all instrumentation were flat.  As the neurosurgeons said: “There was no neural brain activity”.   This was maintained for 60 minutes  At some point, after she was rendered and confirmed brain dead,  She described leaving her body and her “vision” was looking at the operation from the viewpoint from over the shoulder of a surgeon. She saw them take out, what was functionally a saw, that was used to access her skull. It did not look like a saw with a circular blade, It looked like an electric toothbrush or a small hand drill. She saw the case it came in and the extensions looked like drill bits to her .She had never seen I saw like that. She felt perfectly calm and this was usual in NDE..
  • She went towards a light and realized she was in the presence of her grandmother, an uncle and others. She asked if the light was God and it was explained that the light was the breath of God. She says “I am standing in the breath of God” Her uncle tells her she has to go back. She is back looking at her body and see it as dead. He tells her “just Dive and she balks so he nudges her and she is back in her body with a shock.
  •  After the procedure her temperature was brought back up and blood was pumped back into her brain. Then she was revived. After the operation Pam told the doctor about all that she saw while floating above the operating table! Of course, the doctor did not believe at first. His first epistemology is science. The evidence increased.  She “saw” many steps in the operation including the previously unknown instrument used as a saw that were brought out after she was brain dead. She “heard” the conversations and the background music.
  • At this point the only logical conclusion that does not contradict the known facts was that since it is scientifically impossible to see and hear in the operating room with what I will call her earthly eyes and ears, then she saw and heard with what is called her “spirit” eyes and ears. Before going back into her body she experienced her spirit body at the same time she was looking at her earthly body.
  • So, anyone who wants to know that at the time of death, if there is proof, that consciousness leaves the physical body and goes into their spirit body and if that spirit body and consciousness continues, they have the answer.
  • This type floating over the operating table, was repeated and cataloged many times with others  as time went on. In some of those other cases, facts that were unavailable were repeated in detail about known relatives arriving in other rooms after the patient was brain dead.. The overall record on this is not hit and miss.
  • They are scientist. The strictly materialist, view seemed more professional and scientific. Now the had new science-based evidence in their professional arena.  Some had the integrity to believe new science-based evidence. Some were subsequently converted to Christianity (Dr Egnor was) or, simply, belief in God. .
  • There are many other NDE experiences with the same elements. Hovering or even travel in the operating room and other locations while brain dead, followed by detailed observations that are verified as having no alternate explanations.
  • The science of consciousness not operating within the brain is also supported by other studies such split-brain experiments. The material brain is the organ of movement, perception, memory and emotion, but not consciousness.
  • OK – we are now ready to further analyze cataloged data on experiencers of NDE. There is a doctor that started a data base in his internship 30 years ago that has been maintained. Dr Jeffery Long has entered from many sources 5,000 entries. This is well organized.
  • Here is a You Tube video of an interview with Dr Jeffery Long who was an early collector and investigator with a data base of 5000 entries.
  • Dr long has data and is very articulate.
  • https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=groundbreaking+of+4000+nde
  • Paste the above in You Tube top line.
    • Rising over the operating table and observing the frantic activity to resuscitate with summoned crisis medical people and instrument resources.
    • Some observations are made in other rooms or distance. These are consistently accurate in details that were not available to the patient when not brain dead.
    • Intense and generally positive emotions with no fear.
    • Often passing through a tunnel.
    • Approaching a brilliant light and/or other beings. Sometimes loved ones and even pets. Never living persons.
    • Alterations in time and space.
    • Life review (20% of the time) compared to a multi-screen video presentation that recreates their thoughts and the concurrent thoughts of others and the emotional effects. Later the information is validated, even some that was not known before such as sibling that did not live. Gods tolerance is highlighted by the fact that he is not judging them. They are judging themselves and see the effects their actions had on others in deep detail and clarity.
    • Encountering a vast heavenly realm that projects encompassing love at a level that cannot be adequately explained when they return to our world. some targeted Information is given to the with instructions to pass it on.
    • They also recieve guidance on their purpose in life and discussion/option about returning. Sometimes it is already determined that they need to return. The majority do not want to return.
    • Some of the information gained is validated after. No information is contradicted, because not all is meant to be recalled or there is not capacity in the earthly memory.
  • There are numerous, consistent accounts where they meet Jesus (17%) or a light or figure in light that they are certain is God.
  • Their life is permanently changed in purpose and priority.
  • They are often returned cured. Sometimes they return with injuries but are told they will achieve a complete recovery of major threats and this happens in a way that many consider miraculous cures, including their doctors.
  • Here is a You Tube video of an interview with Dr Jeffery Long who was an early collector and investigator with a data base of 5000 entries. Dr long has data and is very articulate.
  • https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RO1-NOfViro&t=61s
  • Paste it in You Tube.

 What has emerged is a top-down architecture that is consistent with many religions. The entire architecture of this realm and its worked and values supported has an aesthetic that is loving, just, compassionate and beautiful beyond its composite details.

Experiencers receive an overwhelming feeling of love that permeates them to the core. The feeling is internal and at a level that is indescribable after they return. This was shared by guides, relatives, and everyone in heaven.

Not everyone rises to the top level of a heavenly realm and meets the one God or Jesus as God. The overall experience is congruent. It is consistent by occurance and overall experience across all cultures and religions. Experiencers feel they have come home and it is explained that spirits leave and come back at different levels of purification as they are reincarnated.

  • God may pass on information that he wants them to promulgate. What they do remember when resuscitated back to life, they remember in detail for the rest of their life. This enhanced memory is consistent even when they have injuries causing brain fog and loss of concentration in other areas. This is concurrence that this special memory is related to their spirit faculties rather than their present, biological, mechanistic brain functions.
  • In addition to this block of memory they have on coming back, there is often a much larger amount of information, but, as explained, this does not fit in their memory capacity on earth.
  •  They feel transformed. They think about it ofen, and are so, guided by its lessons.
  • He wants them to give, to love, and to care one another. He wants this as a gift from Him, through us, to the receivers.
  • Lives are permanently changed with new priorities and a sense of mission, especially in the areas of loving and caring for others.
  • Being a conceptual person all of this is astounding to me. What revelation is more important?
    • This is one way of reacting.
    • A second way is that some people will say and feel they always knew this from faith.
    • A third way is that some people will largely ignore it.
  • Please think about it. We have assurance of eternal life!!

Scientific Reservations vs Belief in Near-Death Experiences

First let’s set the stage for the basics of a logical conclusion that could be used to dismiss or agree on balance.

  • Deduction: derives conclusions that must follow from premises.
    • This is the logic of pure sciences like physics. Data is analyzed and matches algorithms/formulas using known parameters. The highest levels of human behavior do not yield algorithms using standard measurements.
  • Induction: generalizes from observations.
    • Similar to abduction but the states of consciousness discussed here are new territory
  • Abduction: infers the most plausible explanation for observations. This is used if there is not a clear and previous body of work available for Induction – eg: the mental processes below the level of consciousness.
  • So, I will use abduction as a measure of believability.

To assess the validity of near-death experiences as verified fact we have to use an abductive wieghting

Supporters of a non-material interpretation might point to concurrence among:

  • reports from different cultures,
  • recurring features (light, tunnel, life review),
  • transformative psychological aftereffects,
  • occasional claims of veridical perception during clinical death.

Skeptics point to a different concurrence:

  • effects of oxygen deprivation,
  • temporal lobe activity,
  • ketamine-like experiences,
  • known mechanisms of memory reconstruction,
  • brain activity observed during critical states.

Both sides are engaged in abductive reasoning.

The debate is not:”Can we deduce consciousness survives death?” Rather it is: “Which explanation best accounts for the full pattern of observations?” Given the immensity of the claims concerning the whole picture claimed, At a very high level:

  1. A whole new realm, not material, in addition to our material universe.
  2. Populated with spirits: God angels, guides, past relatives and some claims of evil interceptors.
  3. Experiencers are permeated with intensive feelings of being loved and loving others.  Feelings of being home and detachment from former material state.
  4. Sights, sounds, story lines, a complex system of moral justice.
  5. Life Review: without external imposition of blame, internal insight of mistakes and feeling of others.
  6. Reincarnation choices, return choices. Various levels of spiritual advancement and knowledge of eternal existence as a spirit.
  7. Those who experience NDE (Experiencers) have a spirit appearance of a ball of light or a material body analog, greatly enhanced vision, 360 degree vision, better hearing,
  8. Communication by thought sharing,
  9. Veridical perception is the  reporting of events, objects, or conversations that occurred while the person was unconscious, clinically dead, or otherwise unable to perceive them through normal sensory channels.  These details are later confirmed by witnesses, medical records, or other objective evidence, making them “verified” in the scientific sense.

The  skeptics claims do not stand up to the experiences of NDE experiencers. There are perceptual effects as mentioned like tunnel vision during oxygen deprivation. There are spurts of visions and hallucinations. These are verified as happening during treatment. I will not refute this by my opinion. I do refer Youtube where you put in “NDE and  anesthesiologist” or “NDE and neuroscientist” or ICU nurses. You will get Dr Hameroff and Dr Michael Egnor and many others. Dealing with NDE is the most high impact emergence in their careers and they reject all of the above.

What is not covered by the skeptics? Consider: if a patient were blind, medically EKG flat, with their heart stopped then they are medically brain dead. A skeptic would have to say that a blind person, who is an experiencer could not see because they do not have a perfect spirit body or any spirit body.  Guess what? NDE experiencers who are blind are able to see – better than any earthly vision, Deaf or severely hearing impaired who could not hear or or hear well hear better than any earthly person.  This is the biggest stopping  point in medical terms. Why is it not addressed. After

Skeptics are also positing that all these related stories are from the last vestiges of a dying brain. How come a million people a year have a similar dream elements throughout history and across all cultures. The experience changes there entire future life in priority, religion with a memory more vivid than any other. Is there any other such dream under any circumstances. Believed by Neurologist/scientist, ICU/CCU personal, with decades of experience. reasoning.  Here is an additional reference.

Near-Death Experiences That Were Verified: Real Cases

https://projectprofound.org/blog/verified-near-death-experience-cases

How stretched is this line of abductive refusal.

 

 

 

To contact me since the comment mechanism does not always work, you can email be at jimsullivannj@comcast.net